This is the July 2003 judgment in the appeal passed by Lord Justice Sedley regarding the court case in the link above. He concluded that "the medical evidence relied on by the two mothers to show that vaccination is dangerous and unnecessary was untenable. Dr Donegan's report was based on no independent research, and most of the published papers cited by her in support of her views turned out either to support the contrary position or at least to give no support to her own. Not to mince words, the court below was presented with junk science." [Dr Jayne Donegan, a GP and homeopath, appeared as an expert witness.]